Category Archives: Macroeconomics & Money

Fin De Siecle?: Is the Economy at the End Of an Era?

Listener 19 December 1998.

Keywords: Macroeconomics & Money;

There will be frequent reference next year, to repeating the “fin de siecle”, a movement of decadence at the end of the nineteenth century. However the economic end of an era may be this year. If so, it will be identified with the Russian financial crisis of August 1998. This is not because of the size of the economy, but rather numerous financial institutions were heavily exposed to Russian debt. Some were highly “leveraged”, with a high debt to equity ratio, and are very vulnerable. One hedge fund had a liquidity crisis, others have taken a terrible financial pounding.

Data Doldrums: The State Of the Economy Won’t Do National Any Favours in The Poll

Listener: 23 October, 1999

Keywords: Macroeconomics & Money;

Two major economic indicators for the June quarter were released a couple of days before the Prime Minister announced the election date. Both were depressing: the current account deficit – how much New Zealand has to borrow overseas – was at near record levels; while GDP – how much New Zealand produces – declined. There will be no further major official statistics released before November 27th, although the importance of each minor one will be over-played. (Both the Treasury and the Reserve Bank macro-economic forecasts published during the election campaign are likely to be more subdued in comparison to their last ones.)

The Whimpering Of the State: Policy After MMP


Auckland University Press, 1999. 269pp.

The policy process has changed dramatically following the introduction of MMP. Fascinated by the theatre of politics, we too easily ignore the major changes in policy approaches and outcomes. Today, without an assured parliamentary majority the government has to consult over its policies rather than impose them. Along with the increasing recognition that the policies of the past have failed, the policy blitzkrieg has almost ceased and commercialisation is being shelved.

The Whimpering of the State looks at the first three MMP years with the same lively, broad -ranging and informed approach as Easton’s successful The Commercialisation of New Zealand, which described the winner-takes-all regime before 1996. Again there are case studies: health, education, science, the arts, taxation. retirement policy, and infrastructure. Policy possibilities are explored. Yet, as the title of the book suggests, any releif from the ending of Rogernomics is offset be a realistic pessimism arising from a shrewd analysis of the continuing deficiencies in New Zealand’s political and social structure. Although written for the general public, this book will also be read by politicians, policy analysts and students, and will shape policy thinking in the MMP era. Publisher’s Blurb

The Green Tiger: The Irish Can Joke About New Zealand

Listener 19 June, 1999

Keywords: Globalisation & Trade; Macroeconomics & Money;

The OECD report on the Irish economy, released this month, is unusually fulsome about their economy, describing its performance as “stunning” and “the envy of countries around the world.” They were referring to the last three years, but they could have been referring to the last fifteen. The accompanying table shows an annual GDP growth rate of 6 percent, high employment and productivity growth, low inflation, a balance of payments surplus, and the almost halving of unemployment.The feat is all the more extraordinary because their economic performance before 1985 was worse than New Zealand’s. Between 1978 and 1985 Irish employment actually fell, consumer inflation was marginally higher than ours, and at 8 percent of GDP the current account deficit was even larger than New Zealand’s is today.

When Things Go Bump: Is Monetary Union a Help or a Hindrance?

Listener 5 June 1999

Keywords: Macroeconomics & Money;

The Cook Islands lost 13 percent of its population in the last two years, about the same as New Zealand losing Christchurch. The economy suffered some severe external shocks – mainly from New Zealand – which contracted the economy. The government tried to spend its way out of the crisis, ran out of foreign currency, and the consequential cuts plunged the economy into depression and unemployment.

Means to an End: Social Radicals Who Are Fiscal Conservatives

Listener 8 May 1999

Keywords: Macroeconomics & Money;

Michael Cullen and Helen Clark are fiscal conservatives. They think there is a practical constraint to the size of the government’s budget deficit: they may well prefer it to be in a surplus. While they may think, as sophisticate Keynesians, the size of the deficit should vary over the business cycle as a part of demand management, in the long run they see the internal deficit as constrained. However much of their Labour Party are not fiscal conservatives. In government, already evidently in opposition, Labour will face tensions because much of their caucus – even the cabinet – are not so committed to fiscal austerity.

Possibilities: Could New Zealand Have a Financial Crisis?

Listener 24 April 1999.

Keywords: Macroeconomics & Money;

If it were possible to predict the precise timing of a financial crisis, everyone would take precautions, and precipitate an earlier one. However the footnote has three lists of indicators. My scorecard for New Zealand gives 5 out 8 for macroeconomic performance factors and 5 out of 7 for macroeconomic policy factors (although some of our policy changes were more than a decade ago). But for microeconomic conditions (which the conventional wisdom says is the more important), I reckon it is 0 out of 8 (assuming reasonably competent bank management – who can tell until after the event?). Moreover, with one small exception all New Zealand banks are owned overseas. Megabank International will quickly and quietly bail out Megabank New Zealand if gets it into trouble, to protect its reputation elsewhere.

Constant Crises: It Is True – There Are More Of Them

Listener: 10 April, 1999.

Keywords: Macroeconomics & Money;

The worldwide trend of financial liberalisation since the early 1980s seems to have resulted in more financial crises. These include currency crises, where the foreign exchange market is disrupted, forcing the government to change its exchange rate regime (frequently either changing the peg of the fixed exchange rate, or shifting to some sort of floating regime). New Zealand had a currency crisis in July 1984 when there was a fixed exchange rate, and so much conversion of New Zealand into foreign denominated financial assets that the Reserve Bank (which funded the conversion) became short of foreign currency.

Questions, Questions, Questions … for Macroeconomic Forecasters

Listener 13 March, 1999

Keywords: Macroeconomics & Money;

Sometimes public comment on forecasts focuses on the statistics, and ignores that there ought to be an underlying account of the state of the economy. With the March quarter round of forecasts underway, it may be useful to set down the some of the questions that top forecasters are pondering.

When Capital Flees: the Case for Exchange Controls Is Not out Of This World

Listener 17 October, 1998.

Keywords: Globalisation & Trade; Macroeconomics & Money;

While I was recently analyzing a government report for a class, a student (who apparently worked on it) became increasingly agitated, asking what was my alternative proposal. Not worrying about analysis, but pursuing policy, is a characteristic Wellington foible. The same fallacy applied to the economists who criticized economist Paul Krugman when he was here. They did not suffer from the disadvantage of having read his analysis, which was considerably more subtle and sophisticated than the critics thought. You dont successfully spend time in top US university economics common rooms and the US economics circuit, without developing powerful defences to the elementary points the New Zealand critics made.

Intrigue and Deep Recession: Something Rotten in the State Of the Economy?

Listener 26 September, 1998.

Keywords: Macroeconomics & Money;

Kenneth Branagh’s uncut version of Hamlet reminded us that while the depressed prince dithered and the court of Elisnore intrigued, Fortinbras of Norway invaded and conquered Denmark. Is there a parallel with the pettiness in our parliament, while the economy goes into what looks to be a deep recession? It had begun its downswing stage of the business cycle by the middle of last year, before the Asian crisis began. So the looming collapse of Asian export markets and commodity prices reinforced what was going to be a difficult time anyway.

Heretic to High Priest: Krugman ‘sort of’ Predicted the Asian Crisis Three Years Earlier

Listener: 15 August, 1998

Keywords Business & Finance, Globalisation & Trade, History of Ideas, Methodology & Philosophy, Macroeconomics & Money

“A decade ago, he was the most celebrated heretic. Today, Paul Krugman is the high priest of economics, his career transformed by the unintended consequences of his own iconoclasm. Some of his radical instincts remain; but they now serve a different purpose. The vigour with which Krugman once probed the outer limits of economics is now used to protect its core values. Through his popular writings, he defends the dismal science by exposing fallacies in the public discussion of economics issues.” (Prospect, April 1998)

Swing Low: a Short Economic History Of New Zealand

Listener 1 August 1998.

Keywords: Macroeconomics & Money; Political Economy & History;

The Governor of the Reserve Bank finished a recent speech with “the sharp downturn in may of our export markets may well turn out to be the most serious shock to it the New Zealand economy since the oil shock of the seventies.” Here is a summary of the main shocks and recessions over our economic history.

The Politics and Sociology Of Economic Forecasting

This is an extended version of an article published in The New Zealand Herald July 7, 1998.

Keywords: Macroeconomics & Money;

Last week parliamentary leader of ACT, Richard Prebble, called for the resignation of the Secretary of the Treasury, Alan Bollard, because of inadequate Treasury economic forecasts. The call is so political that it may be dismissed as silly, but it also raises wider questions about economic forecasting in general.

In Stormy Seas: Can We Cope when a Wave Broadsides Our Economy?

Listener 4 July, 1998.

Keywords: Growth & Innovation; Macroeconomics & Money;

“Small open economies are like rowing boats on an open sea. One cannot predict when they might capsize; bad steering increases the chances of disaster and a leaky boat makes it inevitable. But their chances of being broadsided by a wave are significant, no matter how well they are steered and no matter how seaworthy they are.” Joe Stiglitz, World Bank chief economist.

That Sinking Feeling: on Track to Contraction?

Listener 9 May, 1998.

Keywords: Macroeconomics & Money;

Readers of this column will be less surprised than most at the increasingly gloomy state of the New Zealand economy. In a September 1997 column I discussed the expected deterioration in the current of account of the balance of payments. Then the external deficit was running near 5 percent of GDP. The latest figure is 7.7 percent of GDP, which traditionally would be of crisis proportions. Rather than the usual rapid collapse of the exchange rate (or the government defending the existing level by selling foreign exchange), the rate is steadily sinking. Under our floating exchange rate regime, foreign exchange transactors can take forward cover (that is purchase contracts which guarantee they can withdraw New Zealand currency at a fixed rate in the future). This smooths any precipitate descent, so the rate sinks over a long period rather than plummets over a short period.

Ins and Outs: Will There Be a Snap Election over Economic Policy?

Listener 28 February, 1998.

Keywords: Macroeconomics & Money;

While there is a widespread expectation that there will be a snap election, the political arithmetic does not stack up. There is a solid majority of parliamentarians who would suffer personally from an early election, losing there seats, there perks and their power. Even so it is possible that the political scene could change to the point where a majority might think they had a chance if an election was called early.

Microeconomic Reform: the New Zealand Experience

Microeconomic Reform and Productivity Growth: Workshop Proceedings, proceedings of a conference “Microeconomic Reform and Productivity Growth”: 26-27 February 1998. (Productivity Commission and ANU, 1998) p.155-181.

Keywords: Growth & Innovation; Macroeconomics & Money; Political Economy & History;

Prologue

This being the first occasion which I have visited the Australian National University since the death of Professor Fred Gruen, may I briefly pay him a tribute. When we first met, Fred was suspicious of my approach, thinking I was anti-market. Over some long discussions he came to recognize I have a deep Marshallian respect for the market, even though we might not always agree on the details of policy. I would have appreciated a continuation of our intermittent dialogue with his response to this paper. It would have been thoughtful and shrewd. I would have responded in my revision, each of us shifting our position in the light of analysis and facts. I am sorry he is not here, except in spirit.

Introduction

Economic reform in New Zealand has been unusually comprehensive and thorough. For the scientist it provides a test of the theory which underpinned the reforms. The overt theory was essentially that which is known in Australia as “economic rationalism”, the consistent application of modern neo-classical market theory. At the practical microeconomic policy level this has been the withdrawal of government interventions which preferred one firm, industry, or sector (relative to others), in favour of market regulation of economic activity. Thus import licences have been abandoned, tariff levels steadily reduced, subsidies and tax incentives withdrawn, the tax regime made more uniform with exemptions barriers to entry eradicated, corporatization and privatisation of government trading activities, and greater reliance on competition law.1 There remain some (now much lower) tariffs, a few special taxes, occasional interventions, and so on. Nevertheless the extent of the microeconomic reforms is such to that they become a test of the theory which underpins them.

The Year Of the Paper Tiger: Asia Is in Economic As Well As Financial Crisis

Listener 14 February, 1998.

Keywords: Growth & Innovation; Macroeconomics & Money;

This column gets written about a month before it is first read. So there is a discipline to avoid instant comment which will prove facile a few weeks later. But the lead time also limits commenting on a rapidly unfolding scenario, as is occurring in East Asia. I have not been one to assume that the current bailout of this or that country by this or that institution will be the last, nor that the bailout will resolve quickly some underlying problem.

In Stormy Seas: The Post-war New Zealand Economy


Otago University Press, 1997. 343pp.

A detailed look at the New Zealand economy in the twentieth century, and in particular its course since World War II. This is not just a history but a narrative about a problem’, defining, and ‘hopefully contributing to an understanding that will aid to its solutions’.

In Stormy Seas asks pertinent questions about some of our favourite national myths. The intial chapters examine the ongoing debate about the New Zealand economy, looking at such factors as external impact and internal response, the business cycle and growth, and problems of financing investment. Structural transformation, the farm sector, industry and energy, efficiency and flexibility, and ‘the market’ are all explored before the book closes with a discussion of the aftermath of Rogernomics and the decade of greed. (Publisher’s blurb)