Apply the golden fiscal rule and invest prudently. A lender is greatly disadvantaged compared to a borrower. The borrower gets the cash immediately. In exchange, the lender gets a promise that the borrower will repay the loan (plus interest) at some time in the future. No matter how honourable the borrower is, the lender knows…
Continue reading this entry »
If there is a major shock, New Zealand has not got a lot of fiscal room to move. In late 2008, there was the Global Financial Crisis. New Zealand’s orthodox response was a fiscal expansion with a deficit (OBEGAL) of $3.9b in the June 2009 year compared to a fiscal surplus of $5.6b in June…
Continue reading this entry »
The proposal to reduce the number of public servants is not well worked out. Announcing the reduction of 8700 jobs for public servants during the runup to the 2026 election suggests the economy is in a fragile state. The Iran War is generating global stagnation and inflation; even worse – if oil and related products…
Continue reading this entry »
The outlook is gloomy. The Treasury economic forecasts for May budgets are usually settled in April to feed into the fiscal forecasts and, critically, the borrowing program. They can be changed in the interim six weeks if anything happens. (Not too difficult with a fully balanced forecast; I was once involved in a morning rejig…
Continue reading this entry »
We are facing difficult challenges from the likely rise in import prices. Many readers may find this week’s column difficult compared to the discussions they are familiar with. That is because it tries to get the analysis right rather than skipping over the difficult bits and leaving the reader with misunderstandings. So apologies for the…
Continue reading this entry »
We may regret we have not put enough effort into building resilience. I was wrong when I argued that the Muldoon Government should have hiked petrol tax to ration petrol when it ran short following the Second Oil Shock in 1979. The Iran revolution’s reduction of oil output amounted to about 4 percent of world…
Continue reading this entry »
Andrew Sorkin’s new book, 1929: The Greatest Crash in Wall Street History sheds light on how financial markets work. Economists argue over how exactly the Great Depression of the early 1930s occurred. We are pretty much agreed on what happened in New Zealand – our ability to borrow internationally became very limited while the terms…
Continue reading this entry »
Why we want the Reserve Bank to operate independently. Minister of Foreign Affairs Winston Peters was wrong to criticise Governor of the Reserve Bank of New Zealand, Anna Breman, for cosigning a statement with 14 other heads of other central banks (plus two from the Bank of International Settlement). The statement expressed support for the…
Continue reading this entry »
The government is still borrowing for consumption. I do not think anyone understands the politics of the spat between Ruth Richardson, who chairs the Taxpayers Union, and Nicola Willis – including those two. The underlying economic issue is analytically clearer. The technical term for it is ‘fiscal consolidation’. It is easiest to understand it by…
Continue reading this entry »
We should follow the Golden Rule of Fiscal Management and not borrow for consumption in the medium run. Asymmetry is a crucial, but often ignored, feature of credit transactions. You would normally be surprised if a shopkeeper said they would sell you 1kg of apples but not 2kg, even if you offered to pay a…
Continue reading this entry »
Presentation to Wellington Macrogroup Seminar on Debt policy. 7 November 2025; there is a PowerPoint that goes with this presentation. Available on request. This paper argues that we should focus fiscal policy on net worth more than we do. The current obsession with debt ignores the difference between borrowing for investment purposes and borrowing for…
Continue reading this entry »
Queen Elizabeth II famously asked about the 2008 Global Financial Crisis, ‘Why did no one see it coming?’ In fact, many economists (including yours truly) had pointed out that the financial system probably would crash. But we failed to predict what would precipitate the collapse, how severe it would be and when it would happen….
Continue reading this entry »
Our current fiscal settings promise that we will eventually face a public debt explosion. A major cause would arise from the aging population. Is there anything we can do? It has long been known that the ageing population would create future fiscal pressure. It was quantified in the first (2006) Treasury long-term fiscal projection and…
Continue reading this entry »
What the latest Statistics New Zealand GDP figures might be telling us. Statistics New Zealand’s publication of GDP for the June Quarter got a lot of media coverage, some of which bordered on the hysterical. To say the figures demonstrated the country was ‘bankrupt’ is a nonsense. Bankruptcy is about debt. Not a single one…
Continue reading this entry »
What are the economic and political implications if the New Zealand economy stagnates for five and more years? Prime Minister Christopher Luxon told Morning Report that ‘We’ve got the worst recession* we have had in 30 years’. (Observe, he could have said ‘since the Rogernomics Stagnation which finished 30 years ago’, but some things may…
Continue reading this entry »
Why is the British Labour Government penalising its poor? We have the spectacle of the Starmer-led British Labour Government taking measures which are making some of the most struggling Brits worse off. It has got to the point where Labour’s parliamentary backbench is revolting and the government has had to make partial concessions – the…
Continue reading this entry »
What can you do when you have hit your borrowing limit and still want to spend? One option is to cut back on maintenance of your capital – say, to delay repainting the house or keeping the car in tip-top condition. The government does the same. Hence our three water systems leaking, polluting and flooding;…
Continue reading this entry »
Why Government borrowing is limited This column started out to explain how the proposed structural outsourcing of public surgery was partly a consequence of the peculiarities of our fiscal borrowing practices. In summary, the restriction on the government’s debt level means seeking indirect ways to provide the required capital. One way of doing this is…
Continue reading this entry »
Circulated to colleagues The Minister of Health has announced that he expects Health New Zealand to take out ten-year contracts with private health providers to deliver surgery. This is structural outsourcing; it is a form of privatisation (although, no doubt the minister would deny this claim). Whether such long-term outsourcing is efficient is a complicated…
Continue reading this entry »
Monopsonies – dominant purchasers – need to be restrained as much as monopolies – dominant sellers. That is what pay equity is about. This column is not about you-know-who. There are many other political bullies offshore; sometimes there are local ones, as when a politician attacks a group which cannot defend itself or a cabinet…
Continue reading this entry »